This is an extremely important piece of radio, and one that should be widely heard. It geats at an absolutely central question: under what circumstances can these faiths reach some kind of intellectual accomodation? the stories are wonderful, especially of Muslim-Jewish rapprochement in America. My only caveat is: the Christian representative is perhaps not altogether or even very representative of the current state of American Christianity, and hence the real dogmatism is only tangentially engaged. But an excellent and brave start!
It is an excellent piece that deals with the differences between Muslims, Jews and Christians. These differences can be painful and difficult to discuss, but we live in a world where the discussion must take place. This is a heavy piece, and will take considerable concentration to grasp the depth of the production.
If there is a weakness in the program it is that the diversity of voices within Islam and Christianity are more pronounced than those of Judaism in the opening half of the piece. The second half of the program is inspiring because it gives first hand accounts of how hatred and differences can be overcome. The last portion of the piece is a roundtable discussion with all three religions represented and offers a good example of how people can speak about the differences between faith perspectives with respect for others.
Highly recommended as we approach major holy seasons of Jews and Christians.
Comments for With God On Our Side: From Rivalry To Reconciliation
Produced by Richard Paul
Other pieces by Richard Paul
Rating Summary
2 comments
Bill McKibben
Posted on February 24, 2005 at 08:59 AM | Permalink
Review of With God On Our Side: From Rivalry To Reconciliation
This is an extremely important piece of radio, and one that should be widely heard. It geats at an absolutely central question: under what circumstances can these faiths reach some kind of intellectual accomodation? the stories are wonderful, especially of Muslim-Jewish rapprochement in America. My only caveat is: the Christian representative is perhaps not altogether or even very representative of the current state of American Christianity, and hence the real dogmatism is only tangentially engaged. But an excellent and brave start!
Mike Stanton-Rich
Posted on February 11, 2005 at 04:12 PM | Permalink
Review of With God On Our Side: From Rivalry To Reconciliation
It is an excellent piece that deals with the differences between Muslims, Jews and Christians. These differences can be painful and difficult to discuss, but we live in a world where the discussion must take place. This is a heavy piece, and will take considerable concentration to grasp the depth of the production.
If there is a weakness in the program it is that the diversity of voices within Islam and Christianity are more pronounced than those of Judaism in the opening half of the piece. The second half of the program is inspiring because it gives first hand accounts of how hatred and differences can be overcome. The last portion of the piece is a roundtable discussion with all three religions represented and offers a good example of how people can speak about the differences between faith perspectives with respect for others.
Highly recommended as we approach major holy seasons of Jews and Christians.