Comments by Daniel Costello

Comment for "American Purgatory: Political Asylum in the Age of Terrorism" (deleted)

User image

Review of American Purgatory: Political asylum in the age of terrorism (deleted)

A careful examination of the difficult issue of political asylum and how it has changed since the September 11th attacks. Well written and structured, it is strengthened by the personal stories of several asylum seekers and makes a complicated issue approachable and understandable.

Comment for "Voices of Katrina"

User image

Review of Voices of Katrina

These are deeply personal stories of those hardest hit by the catastrophe. Once I got past the cheesy series theme music, I was drawn in for the whole hour. This is a fantastic use of the medium's best asset--the ability to convey emotion. It doesn't get bogged down in preachyness, though--it just tells the people's stories in their own words.

Although the series is targeted to the issues of a specific age group, this special does a great job of making the story accessible to all audiences. It explains the specific problems of the elderly, and why those problems made them the hardest-hit group of those affected by Katrina. The stories are well-chosen and woven together with strong but not intrusive narration.

This is a realistic portrait of an important social issue that doesn't cross over into activist journalism. I might quibble a bit with the musical choices and timing for scoring, but I think that's more a matter of taste.

Take advantage of the news hole, the optional module on Wavy Gravy is good but you should use it somewhere else where it matches better content-wise. I recommend this special for any type of station.